
For my first official post, I’d love to write about some higher form of literature or something, but that’s just not going to happen, so meh. Instead I’m going to rant about Midnight Sun, which is Stephanie Meyer’s Twilight written from the POV of Edward Cullen.
First, to get it off my chest, I really dislike Bella’s character. I’ve seen her described as the ultimate Mary-Sue, and that’s completely true. She doesn’t really have any outstanding personality traits at all, except lame things like trying to be hardcore and anti-mainstream by refusing to like prom/presents/pretty clothes. She’s just a character that’s been put in place for Edward to fall in love with – beyond him, she has no depth at all. A perfect example of this is her life before moving to Forks. The only information we get is a sort of half assed “I didn’t really fit in back home”, and then the entire first 16 years of her life are ignored. She has no past whatsoever beyond her parents, and even that is only included because they are characters in the main story. I’ve read plenty of books in which a character moves to a new place, the Mediator series by Meg Cabot springing to mind, but they always have some sort of tie to the life they used to live, just to make it realistic. Bella has nothing.
So, yes. She whines too much and has no depth. This makes the whole tone of the books kind of irritating, because you’re reading it thinking “God, you’re so stupid” half the time. It’s amazing what changing the point of view can do for the story – everything is exactly the same, and yet it all seems much more developed and interesting.
I have two theories on why this is, the first being the obvious: by the time Stephanie Meyer wrote this book, she already knew the world she had created inside out and back to front. As opposed to when she wrote Twilight, when the whole thing was still new. So, I suppose it’s kind of obvious that Midnight Sun would have more depth.
However, it’s more likely that Edward himself makes this story more interesting. Utter hotness notwithstanding, I think he’s just got alot more depth. He has a past, which is a plus, and also a present that involves more elements than just Bella, such as family issues with Jasper and Rosalie, or even Tanya’s crush on him. Bella’s world seems to revolve entirely around him, but his life existance is much more realistic. The reader even begins to understand why he fell for Bella in the first place, which is quite an achievement considering how irritating she really is.
The other thing that’s interesting about this book is the fact that it’s not being released – it was leaked on the internet and now Stephanie Meyer has decided not to continue writing it. I can’t help but think that this is some kind of marketing ploy. All the hype around the thing will draw alot more people in if she ever does decide to release it – people who had never heard of it before definitely have now. Also, the idea of a novel identical to Twilight, only from a different POV, may not have been something people would have been interested in paying money for. Releasing the first few chapters, however, helps to demonstrate how the book can stand on it’s own, and may induce more people to buy it. Again, if it gets released, lol.